FindAsync and Include LINQ statements

The simplest is to use FirstOrDefaultAsync or SingleOrDefaultAsync instead:

model.Item = await db.Items.Include(i => i.ItemVerifications)
    .FirstOrDefaultAsync(i => i.Id == id.Value);

The reason you are getting the error is because Find / FindAsync methods are defined for DbSet<T>, but the result of Include is IQueryable<T>.

Another way is to combine FindAsync with explicit loading:

model.Item = await db.Items.FindAsync(id);
if (model.Item == null)
{
    return HttpNotFound();
}
await db.Entry(model.Item).Collection(i => i.ItemVerifications).LoadAsync();