Should many to many tables have a primary key?

I agree with everything Oded said except

“It can’t reasonably be used as a
foreign key either.”

In this case it’s a pick your poison, the mapping table absolutely can be a parent, it’s just a matter of the child using a multicolumn FK or not.

Take a simple case of Car and color. Each Year Auto Makers have a certain pallet of colors and each model only comes in limited number of those colors. Many – Many :: Colors to Cars models

So now design the Order table where new cars orders are stored. Clearly Color and Model will be on the Order table. If you make a FK to each of those tables, the database will permit an incorrect model/color combination to be selected. (Of course you can enforce this with code, you can’t do so declaratively.) If you make the parent be the many:many table, you’ll only get combinations that have been specified.

SO would you rather have a multicolumn FK and point to a PK built on both ModelID and ColorID or do you want a single column FK?

Pick your poison.

EDIT

But if it’s not a parent of something, no table needs a surrogate key.

Leave a Comment

Hata!: SQLSTATE[HY000] [1045] Access denied for user 'divattrend_liink'@'localhost' (using password: YES)