Well, you can’t nest ${var%}/${var#} operations, so you’ll have to use temporary variable.
Like here:
var="http://whatever/score/"
temp_var="${var#http://}"
echo "${temp_var%/score/}"
Alternatively, you can use regular expressions with (for example) sed:
some_variable="$( echo "$var" | sed -e 's#^http://##; s#/score/$##' )"