Just throw some Exception if user is not found and catch it in client code while using get(key) method.
new CacheLoader<ObjectId, User>() {
@Override
public User load(ObjectId k) throws Exception {
User u = DataLoader.datastore.find(User.class).field("_id").equal(k).get();
if (u != null) {
return u;
} else {
throw new UserNotFoundException();
}
}
}
From CacheLoader.load(K) Javadoc:
Returns: the value associated with key; must not be null Throws: Exception - if unable to load the result
Answering your doubts about caching null values:
Returns the value associated with key in this cache, first loading
that value if necessary. No observable state associated with this
cache is modified until loading completes.
(from LoadingCache.get(K) Javadoc)
If you throw an exception, load is not considered as complete, so no new value is cached.
EDIT:
Note that in Caffeine, which is sort of Guava cache 2.0 and “provides an in-memory cache using a Google Guava inspired API” you can return null from load method:
Returns: the value associated with key or null if not found
If you may consider migrating, your data loader could freely return when user is not found.