That’s right, according to doc:
Only superusers can create functions in untrusted languages
Quick check:
SELECT lanpltrusted FROM pg_language WHERE lanname LIKE 'c';
lanpltrusted
--------------
f
(1 row)
If you really want this, then you could modify pg_language system catalog (ALTER LANGUAGE doesn’t have such option):
UPDATE pg_language SET lanpltrusted = true WHERE lanname LIKE 'c';
Per user @Otheus below: the UPDATE statement must be done in the DB where the function will reside.