What does it mean when a variable equals a function? [duplicate]

by

Note: Please see the update at the end of the answer, declarations within blocks became valid (but quite complicated if you’re not using strict mode).

Here’s one reason:

var whatever;

if (some_condition) {
    whatever = function() {
        // Do something
    };
}
else {
    whatever = function() {
        // Do something else
    };
}
whatever();

You might see code like that in the initialization of a library that has to handle implementation differences (such as differences between web browsers, a’la IE’s attachEvent vs. the standard addEventListener). You cannot do the equivalent with a function declaration:

if (some_condition) {
    function whatever() {    // <=== DON'T DO THIS
        // Do something
    }
}
else {
    function whatever() {    // <=== IT'S INVALID
        // Do something else
    }
}
whatever();

…they’re not specified within control structures, so JavaScript engines are allowed to do what they want, and different engines have done different things. (Edit: Again, see note below, they’re specified now.)

Separately, there’s a big difference between

var whatever = function() {
    // ...
};

and

function whatever() {
    // ...
}

The first is a function expression, and it’s evaluated when the code reaches that point in the step-by-step execution of the context (e.g., the function it’s in, or the step-by-step execution of global code). It also results in an anonymous function (the variable referring to it has a name, but the function does not, which has implications for helping your tools to help you).

The second is a function declaration, and it’s evaluated upon entry to the context, before any step-by-step code is executed. (Some call this “hoisting” because something further down in the source happens earlier than something higher up in the source.) The function is also given a proper name.

So consider:

function foo() {
    doSomething();
    doSomethingElse();
    console.log("typeof bar = " + typeof bar); // Logs "function"

    function bar() {
    }
}

whereas

function foo() {
    doSomething();
    doSomethingElse();
    console.log("typeof bar = " + typeof bar); // Logs "undefined"

    var bar = function() {
    };
}

In the first example, with the declaration, the declaration is processed before the doSomething and other stepwise code is run. In the second example, because it’s an expression, it’s executed as part of the stepwise code and so the function isn’t defined up above (the variable is defined up above, because var is also “hoisted”).

And winding up: For the moment, you can’t do this in general client-side web stuff:

var bar = function foo() { // <=== Don't do this in client-side code for now
    // ...
};

You should be able to do that, it’s called a named function expression and it’s a function expression that gives the function a proper name. But various JavaScript engines at various times have gotten it wrong, and IE continued to get very wrong indeed until very recently.

Update for ES2015+

As of ES2015 (aka “ES6”), function declarations within blocks were added to the specification.

Strict mode

In strict mode, the newly-specified behavior is simple and easy to understand: They’re scoped to the block in which they occur, and are hoisted to the top of it.

So this:

"use strict";
if (Math.random() < 0.5) {
  foo();
  function foo() {
    console.log("low");
  }
} else {
  foo();
  function foo() {
    console.log("high");
  }
}
console.log(typeof foo); // undefined

(Note how the calls to the functions are above the functions within the blocks.)

…is essentially equivalent to this:

"use strict";
if (Math.random() < 0.5) {
  let foo = function() {
    console.log("low");
  };
  foo();
} else {
  let foo = function() {
    console.log("high");
  };
  foo();
}
console.log(typeof foo); // undefined

Loose mode

Loose mode behavior is much more complex and moreover in theory it varies between JavaScript engines in web browsers and JavaScript engines not in web browsers. I won’t get into it here. Just don’t do it. If you insist on function declarations within blocks, use strict mode, where they make sense and are consistent across environments.

Leave a Comment